from the JTSA weekly torah commentary email:
A stretch for humans comes naturally to animals. We prefer
dependence. The midrash comments on the verse in Job: "Who
has given understanding to the cock (38:36)?" which is also
the text for the first of the daily blessings in the
morning service. Wisdom is encoded into nature by God.
Taking the word sekhvi as hen rather than cock, the midrash
describes a common barnyard scene. The hen gathers her tiny
chicks under her wings, warms them and leads them around.
But once they are grown, let one try to return and the hen
will peck at his head, saying go dig for your own food.
To achieve its expanded reading of the text, midrash turns
legislation into narrative. Not only does the conquest of
Canaan require of us to work the land, it also imposes on
us the obligations to steward it responsibly. We are
expected to preserve its life-sustaining resources
undepleted for our children. We found the land covered with
trees planted by others when we entered it, says the
midrash, and that is how we are supposed to hand it on. No
one is ever to say I am too old to worry about the welfare
of the next generation.
And then the midrash recounts that the Roman emperor
Hadrian once passed through Palestine on his way to war in
the east, where he happened upon an elderly Jew planting
fig trees. The sight of such altruism prompted the emperor
to ask the man his motives. "My lord, the king," said the
man, "I trouble myself to plant because if I merit it, I
myself shall eat of the fruits of my labor. And if not,
then my children will."
Three years later, Hadrian returned to that self-same spot
in Palestine to be greeted by the elderly farmer with a
basket full of fresh figs. He reminded the emperor of their
previous conversation and gave him the figs. Awed by the
man's lack of self-centeredness, Hadrian returned his
basket full of Roman gold coins.
The midrash reiterates its lesson: Let no one ever cease
from planting. Fields filled with trees greeted us at
birth, and we should add to their number even in old age.
For God has already taught us by example that personal
gain is too narrow a base for human behavior, as it is
written, "The Lord God planted a garden in Eden, in the
east (Genesis 2:8)," surely done for human benefit,
without any thought of self.
So in the midst of a parasha that teaches us how to relate
to family, fellow human (both native and foreign) and God,
the midrash adds yet a fourth dimension: our treatment of
the habitat in which we live. The midrash resonates with an
environmental ethic reinforced by language. In rabbinic
Hebrew the word "shoots," netiot (from the root "to plant")
takes on a metaphoric meaning of "children." The
convergence of meanings helps us move beyond our selves, or
better to see ourselves in that which lies beyond us. For
all our wisdom and consciousness, humans are not endowed
with much of a capacity to see ahead. The long term
consequences of our actions rarely enter into the
calculations behind our choices. Thus the overlapping
meanings of netiot, the subtle nuances of language, throw
up a gentle reminder to think of our children...
A stretch for humans comes naturally to animals. We prefer
dependence. The midrash comments on the verse in Job: "Who
has given understanding to the cock (38:36)?" which is also
the text for the first of the daily blessings in the
morning service. Wisdom is encoded into nature by God.
Taking the word sekhvi as hen rather than cock, the midrash
describes a common barnyard scene. The hen gathers her tiny
chicks under her wings, warms them and leads them around.
But once they are grown, let one try to return and the hen
will peck at his head, saying go dig for your own food.
To achieve its expanded reading of the text, midrash turns
legislation into narrative. Not only does the conquest of
Canaan require of us to work the land, it also imposes on
us the obligations to steward it responsibly. We are
expected to preserve its life-sustaining resources
undepleted for our children. We found the land covered with
trees planted by others when we entered it, says the
midrash, and that is how we are supposed to hand it on. No
one is ever to say I am too old to worry about the welfare
of the next generation.
And then the midrash recounts that the Roman emperor
Hadrian once passed through Palestine on his way to war in
the east, where he happened upon an elderly Jew planting
fig trees. The sight of such altruism prompted the emperor
to ask the man his motives. "My lord, the king," said the
man, "I trouble myself to plant because if I merit it, I
myself shall eat of the fruits of my labor. And if not,
then my children will."
Three years later, Hadrian returned to that self-same spot
in Palestine to be greeted by the elderly farmer with a
basket full of fresh figs. He reminded the emperor of their
previous conversation and gave him the figs. Awed by the
man's lack of self-centeredness, Hadrian returned his
basket full of Roman gold coins.
The midrash reiterates its lesson: Let no one ever cease
from planting. Fields filled with trees greeted us at
birth, and we should add to their number even in old age.
For God has already taught us by example that personal
gain is too narrow a base for human behavior, as it is
written, "The Lord God planted a garden in Eden, in the
east (Genesis 2:8)," surely done for human benefit,
without any thought of self.
So in the midst of a parasha that teaches us how to relate
to family, fellow human (both native and foreign) and God,
the midrash adds yet a fourth dimension: our treatment of
the habitat in which we live. The midrash resonates with an
environmental ethic reinforced by language. In rabbinic
Hebrew the word "shoots," netiot (from the root "to plant")
takes on a metaphoric meaning of "children." The
convergence of meanings helps us move beyond our selves, or
better to see ourselves in that which lies beyond us. For
all our wisdom and consciousness, humans are not endowed
with much of a capacity to see ahead. The long term
consequences of our actions rarely enter into the
calculations behind our choices. Thus the overlapping
meanings of netiot, the subtle nuances of language, throw
up a gentle reminder to think of our children...
