I went to see the Thunderbird Native American dancers last night. What suprised me was the level of storytelling that was within each dance - it was a string of actions, which transmitted something to the witness. There's something about storytelling - to bring the thought full-circle, a story is a dance, with precise (but not exact) changes in rythm and voice. We like to think ourselves capable of any action, but I think the truth is that life blunts and blurs our ability to tell stories, or to create an action. To offset that, we rely on "culture", which contains in its rythms and movements the full "skill-set" which a human life requires.
It reminds me of a performance of Bread and Puppet (a great Vermont-based experimental theatre) that I saw, where the grizzled director introduced the skit of "Kicking the Government in the Ass". It was Punch & Judy cliche-comic, to be sure, but at the moment before the actual kick, the director/narrator (Peter Schumann, an outstanding breadbaker) halted the action, and in a very serious way, asked the actors to consider what it was they were about to do, and to do it mindfully. They proceeded then with the action. But something had been created in them by doing so. They were practicing the ability to deal with an overwhelmingly powerful force on their own terms. That action was now in their "skill-set" - and the ability to create that action moved forward in time.
I got to Columbus Circle at 10:30AM. A few dozen folks were milling around - no one I knew, so I took the chance to get a cup of coffee and some cashews. Slowly, the crowd began to grow, finally numbering about 300 (counting the folks on the south side of CPS). It was a mix of the radicals who dabbled in theatre and vice versa, and I certainly didn't feel out of place in blazer, overcoat & hat. There was a lot of milling about. I don't know when the crowd started moving west, but Bread & Puppet led the way, with a long file of women dressed in black with paper-mache faces, carrying puppet corpses. Then came the band, and after them, the banners. I fell in with the banners, taking an extra one.
The progress was very slow across the base of the park. We were on the sidewalk, stopping at crosswalks. At the Southeast corner of the park, Labor joined the parade. The walk was slooooow. I had come down with a bit of a stomach thing the night before as a result of a cheap indian dinner with way too much cardamon & garlic, an ice-cold bedroom, and wet blankets from a malfunctioning dryer. So I was mainly focussed on intestinal alignment for the first hour or so.
The crowd was an amicable mix of older ladies from upstate, young families, world-famous economists (yep, saw one), and artists. There were a few folks in black encouraging us to push the envelope (the movement from the sidewalk to the street was technically illegal, and one sensed that it was the moment when many young families realized the conversations that night at the dinner table would be longer than expected), but these nighted-colored folks weren't the same species as the WEF/Davos/Seattle ones. Much more tame. Or else, I'm less tame than I thought. Anyways, when we got to the base of the Roosevelt Island tram, we collectively realized that the police weren't going to let us go any farther. So Bread & Puppet struck the puppets, and I slipped back through the crowd, and headed north via Third.
(There is an art to getting around crowded New York events. The police will try to pen you up behind barriers, and the unaware usually find themselves penned in at the stroke of midnight seven blocks from anywhere that could remotely be described as Times Square. The savvier folks, however, know that it is wiser to navigate north to south until you find an open cross-street, and to move into the area in the direction exactly opposite to the way that the vast majority of folks are moving into it.)
I skirted the North side of the rally - it was just before 1PM, and I crossed First Ave at 70th street (stopping to use the McBathroom), and headed South on York, one block east of the rally.
I was stopped by a cop.
"Are you protesting?" (Implication: if you are, you can't continue on.)
(Slight pause, to allow the oddness of the question, especially addressed to someone on a quiet, empty block who wasn't wearing any buttons or carrying any signs.)
"What do you mean?" ("I am, and we're going to play a little game.")
"Are you, eh, part of the protest thing, or do you live here?"
"I live in Manhattan."
"Hum, OK then."
So I kept going, and crossed over to First somewhere in the sixties, I think. After milling around a bit in the pen, I decided to move back West, since I couldn't hear a word of the speeches, and I didn't feel like standing in a cattle yard. I could see the big-screen TV above the podium from where I stood though, and one of the speakers seemed to have on a Native American head-dress.
Then things got interesting.
You see, the vast majority of people had approached from the Southeast, and there was now an elaborate network of roadblocks and riot police deployed to impede any East-West movement below 70th Street. Second avenue was filled with a stream of people moving north. I joined in for a few blocks, then cut over to Third Avenue. There, the crowd was less directional, because every four blocks or so, the police had decided to engage the protesters with massive force, and the protesters channelled their numbers to these pressure-points. From time to time, there would be a break in the lines, and a stream of protesters would sprint to the east, cavorting and screaming in triumph (of course, they were still headed towards more riot police in the two blocks between them and first, but the huge cheers that would erupt from the intersection made their victory very palpable.) A city bus was trapped in the mob, and some elderly protesters decided to pay the fare & rest comfortably, waving their signs out the window.
Horseback units trotted smack into the crowd in a single file, and then split the people, pushing each side back to the sidewalk. Underneath it all was the chanting of thousands, plus drums, horns,and whatever else. (I saw one lady with a conch shell.)
At this point, I considered myself to be an "artistic observer". (Kind of like a "legal observer", but less grad-school debt.) I managed to stay clear of any direct contact by keeping aware of when a "fourth side" was about to be added to the walls of horses, police vans, and whatever else - like in the old computer game "Tron" when the trick was never to let yourself get boxed in, no matter what scale.
It's important to note that this was not a peaceful protest. There was no aggression on the marchers' part, but there was a clear causus belli - the police were keeping them from getting to the rally, and they wanted to get to the rally. People were screaming & yelling, and (most disturbingly) the police treated them as an enemy. No light-blue friendly officers to be seen - this was an incarnation of civic disorder being confronted with Civic Order. One of the most pervasive chants was: Whose Streets? OUR STREETS!.
As a result of this war, something wonderful happened. There was a real sense that where the marchers held the streets, there was freedom. An entire half-block on Fourth Ave in the 40's was filled with people singing "Give peace a chance". Drum circles proliferated. It was as if, having to fight for their right to be there, New Yorkers had suddenly discovered that streets were good for something other than shopping and hurrying to work.
Groups broke off and wandered though midtown, chanting and singing for most of the afternoon. It was very interesting to watch the eyes of the tourists who encountered these bands. It was almost exactly the same as an audience member's reaction to an actor who has acknowleged his presence by delivering a line to him - innocuous bemusement or a studied nonresponse. Times Square was shut down briefly by protesters, and then for a much longer time by riot police.
I had some things to do downtown, and two interesting things happened. As I walked past the large black cube-sculpture at Astor place, two girls were spinning it around and around on its corner. Now, I had been told several times that it moved, but I'd never actually seen it do so. Something about that huge black cube, whirling around to the left, balanced on a corner.... And on the subway back uptown, I was standing next to a policeman who had evidently been deployed to midtown, and was taking the #6 to his station, riot gear in hand. I stood next to him, as I had stood next to an angry and fearful triple line of police, sticks drawn, in the middle of a thousand screaming people a few hours before. The train slowed, then stopped. Stillness. The lights flashed. And then we contiunued.
It reminds me of a performance of Bread and Puppet (a great Vermont-based experimental theatre) that I saw, where the grizzled director introduced the skit of "Kicking the Government in the Ass". It was Punch & Judy cliche-comic, to be sure, but at the moment before the actual kick, the director/narrator (Peter Schumann, an outstanding breadbaker) halted the action, and in a very serious way, asked the actors to consider what it was they were about to do, and to do it mindfully. They proceeded then with the action. But something had been created in them by doing so. They were practicing the ability to deal with an overwhelmingly powerful force on their own terms. That action was now in their "skill-set" - and the ability to create that action moved forward in time.
I got to Columbus Circle at 10:30AM. A few dozen folks were milling around - no one I knew, so I took the chance to get a cup of coffee and some cashews. Slowly, the crowd began to grow, finally numbering about 300 (counting the folks on the south side of CPS). It was a mix of the radicals who dabbled in theatre and vice versa, and I certainly didn't feel out of place in blazer, overcoat & hat. There was a lot of milling about. I don't know when the crowd started moving west, but Bread & Puppet led the way, with a long file of women dressed in black with paper-mache faces, carrying puppet corpses. Then came the band, and after them, the banners. I fell in with the banners, taking an extra one.
The progress was very slow across the base of the park. We were on the sidewalk, stopping at crosswalks. At the Southeast corner of the park, Labor joined the parade. The walk was slooooow. I had come down with a bit of a stomach thing the night before as a result of a cheap indian dinner with way too much cardamon & garlic, an ice-cold bedroom, and wet blankets from a malfunctioning dryer. So I was mainly focussed on intestinal alignment for the first hour or so.
The crowd was an amicable mix of older ladies from upstate, young families, world-famous economists (yep, saw one), and artists. There were a few folks in black encouraging us to push the envelope (the movement from the sidewalk to the street was technically illegal, and one sensed that it was the moment when many young families realized the conversations that night at the dinner table would be longer than expected), but these nighted-colored folks weren't the same species as the WEF/Davos/Seattle ones. Much more tame. Or else, I'm less tame than I thought. Anyways, when we got to the base of the Roosevelt Island tram, we collectively realized that the police weren't going to let us go any farther. So Bread & Puppet struck the puppets, and I slipped back through the crowd, and headed north via Third.
(There is an art to getting around crowded New York events. The police will try to pen you up behind barriers, and the unaware usually find themselves penned in at the stroke of midnight seven blocks from anywhere that could remotely be described as Times Square. The savvier folks, however, know that it is wiser to navigate north to south until you find an open cross-street, and to move into the area in the direction exactly opposite to the way that the vast majority of folks are moving into it.)
I skirted the North side of the rally - it was just before 1PM, and I crossed First Ave at 70th street (stopping to use the McBathroom), and headed South on York, one block east of the rally.
I was stopped by a cop.
"Are you protesting?" (Implication: if you are, you can't continue on.)
(Slight pause, to allow the oddness of the question, especially addressed to someone on a quiet, empty block who wasn't wearing any buttons or carrying any signs.)
"What do you mean?" ("I am, and we're going to play a little game.")
"Are you, eh, part of the protest thing, or do you live here?"
"I live in Manhattan."
"Hum, OK then."
So I kept going, and crossed over to First somewhere in the sixties, I think. After milling around a bit in the pen, I decided to move back West, since I couldn't hear a word of the speeches, and I didn't feel like standing in a cattle yard. I could see the big-screen TV above the podium from where I stood though, and one of the speakers seemed to have on a Native American head-dress.
Then things got interesting.
You see, the vast majority of people had approached from the Southeast, and there was now an elaborate network of roadblocks and riot police deployed to impede any East-West movement below 70th Street. Second avenue was filled with a stream of people moving north. I joined in for a few blocks, then cut over to Third Avenue. There, the crowd was less directional, because every four blocks or so, the police had decided to engage the protesters with massive force, and the protesters channelled their numbers to these pressure-points. From time to time, there would be a break in the lines, and a stream of protesters would sprint to the east, cavorting and screaming in triumph (of course, they were still headed towards more riot police in the two blocks between them and first, but the huge cheers that would erupt from the intersection made their victory very palpable.) A city bus was trapped in the mob, and some elderly protesters decided to pay the fare & rest comfortably, waving their signs out the window.
Horseback units trotted smack into the crowd in a single file, and then split the people, pushing each side back to the sidewalk. Underneath it all was the chanting of thousands, plus drums, horns,and whatever else. (I saw one lady with a conch shell.)
At this point, I considered myself to be an "artistic observer". (Kind of like a "legal observer", but less grad-school debt.) I managed to stay clear of any direct contact by keeping aware of when a "fourth side" was about to be added to the walls of horses, police vans, and whatever else - like in the old computer game "Tron" when the trick was never to let yourself get boxed in, no matter what scale.
It's important to note that this was not a peaceful protest. There was no aggression on the marchers' part, but there was a clear causus belli - the police were keeping them from getting to the rally, and they wanted to get to the rally. People were screaming & yelling, and (most disturbingly) the police treated them as an enemy. No light-blue friendly officers to be seen - this was an incarnation of civic disorder being confronted with Civic Order. One of the most pervasive chants was: Whose Streets? OUR STREETS!.
As a result of this war, something wonderful happened. There was a real sense that where the marchers held the streets, there was freedom. An entire half-block on Fourth Ave in the 40's was filled with people singing "Give peace a chance". Drum circles proliferated. It was as if, having to fight for their right to be there, New Yorkers had suddenly discovered that streets were good for something other than shopping and hurrying to work.
Groups broke off and wandered though midtown, chanting and singing for most of the afternoon. It was very interesting to watch the eyes of the tourists who encountered these bands. It was almost exactly the same as an audience member's reaction to an actor who has acknowleged his presence by delivering a line to him - innocuous bemusement or a studied nonresponse. Times Square was shut down briefly by protesters, and then for a much longer time by riot police.
I had some things to do downtown, and two interesting things happened. As I walked past the large black cube-sculpture at Astor place, two girls were spinning it around and around on its corner. Now, I had been told several times that it moved, but I'd never actually seen it do so. Something about that huge black cube, whirling around to the left, balanced on a corner.... And on the subway back uptown, I was standing next to a policeman who had evidently been deployed to midtown, and was taking the #6 to his station, riot gear in hand. I stood next to him, as I had stood next to an angry and fearful triple line of police, sticks drawn, in the middle of a thousand screaming people a few hours before. The train slowed, then stopped. Stillness. The lights flashed. And then we contiunued.
